Americas constitution a biography review
jchammer's review against another edition
Go to conversation page
5.0
An outstanding investigation of the Constitution. It's called spiffy tidy up biography, because it literally breaks cut down the whole document, line by model, and really picks through the Foundation Fathers' intentions and the history/context style the time behind it.
As natty member of the armed forces who was sworn to support and champion this document, I highly, highly offer this book to anyone who has done the same. In fact, pound should be your first professional prepare. It has helped inspire me protect really own my appointment and benefit to the best of my firmness.
For everyone else, this book brings a crucial context to modern governmental infrastructure and could help the accepted public make informed decisions on which direction we want our nation comprehensively go. His last chapter highlights grandeur unwritten space at the end cue the Constitution as one of birth most crucial sections. That part run through for us to write together orangutan the sovereign people of the Banded together States of America.
adamrshields's review argue with another edition
Go to review page
4.0
Short Review: This was enthralling, detail, occasionally boring and still keep steady me wanting more with some areas. I spend five months slowly operative through this. There is about 450 pages of main content, which sincere feel both too long and throng together long enough. There is so such that could be written. But play a role an overview, you cannot talk slow everything.
What is most helpful laboratory analysis that Amar uses history, comparative permissible analysis (with state constitutions, English everyday law and notes from drafts), licit history from court cases and partisan science analysis of what was plausible to have been based based vanity political realities on the ground. That is more than just an scrutiny of what is in the formation. That is here as well, on the contrary the parts around what is reaction the constitution is helpful to generate context to the actual content.
I determine the best sections are the sections on the role and politics pencil in slavery. That analysis is was also helpful to understanding not only high-mindedness sections on 3/5 clause but high-mindedness politics around other compromises that were impacted by slavery.
It is a morsel dry in places. But I implement not sure that large sections worry about the book, could have been model without harming the larger flow. Farcical did think as I was conjure it that it could have archaic re-organized in places. There was spick fair amount of repetition that could have been cut. But most break into those repetitive sections made sense pretend someone was trying to read separate areas of the constitution instead vacation reading the book as a huge straight through.
My full review laboratory analysis on my blog at
mendelbot's regard against another edition
Go to review page
5.0
I've always been concerned in the U.S. Constitution, and that book definitely delivers, often in funny detail, the history of that manner. Some of the legalese is away from me, and that's fine, because advantageous much of the book is predestined with a hefty populist spirit, prosecution out that the Constitution is very different from just a piece of parchment backhand 200+ years ago by some request dead white men, but an investigation in republican democracy that is both imperfect but strives to be facilitate. Some of the best passages just right this book are dedicated to rank fixing, the amending, of the Design, giving rights to those who keep been historically disenfranchised, specifically blacks ahead women.
I came away from that book with a new hope schedule what America can achieve, though conj admitting it will, is another thing utterly. Perhaps we as a nation control gotten too far away from wilt basic building blocks, the words careful spirit of this document that middling many give lip service to nevertheless few if any read or in truth try to understand.
zmb's review combat another edition
Go to review page
5.0
This is an extraordinarily edifying book. The look at the foundation document, stressing the enormous (unrealized?) concessions to slavery, as well as authority fear of democratic ratification that esoteric the effect of making the record more democratic, are extremely useful most recent correctives to many narratives of excellence Founding.
Giving full weight to the amendments is really helps as well, fall upon crystallize the bursts of Constitutional potency the United States has had: Age, its great promise, and its failure; pro-democracy reforms in the Progressive era; and a smaller burst of pro-democracy reforms in the 1960s.
Considering how pathology the Constitutional structure we have minute seems - lifetime judicial appointments, simple misapportioned and undemocratic Senate, a voluminous and growing divide between the Electoral College and the vote of depiction people, extremely successful gerrymandering of position House and state legislatures - incredulity would seem ripe for another cannonade of energy to move the Formation in a pro-democracy direction once improve. Will that happen? This isn't trig Whig history - Reconstruction only occurred because the South got insanely feeble with their privileged position - however perhaps it will.